NEWS

CMOs, DMs in UP directed to take action against AYUSH doctors prescribing allopathic medicines

Friday, June 1, 2012

Allahabad: Allahabad High Court has directed chief medical officers (CMOs) and district magistrates (DMs) in the state to initiate prosecution against those AYUSH (Ayurveda, Yoga, Unani, Siddha and Homeopathy) practitioners who administer allopathic medicines to their patients.

The High Court has also ordered to conduct raids in clinics and nursing homes of such practitioners and prohibit those practitioners from practising modern system of medicine. The court said besides initiating prosecution, an FIR should be lodged and those clinics/nursing homes should be sealed.

In his judgement on the contempt application filed by Rajesh Kumar Srivastava, Justice Sunil Ambwani also directed the chief secretary and the principal health secretary to comply with the earlier orders passed by the court prohibiting unqualified and unregistered persons from practising modern medicine. [Source: Pharmabiz]

Categories: NEWS

Tags: , , , , , , ,

  More from NEWS

Healthcare should be a mission with ethical & moral values: Rajnath Singh


Biosense Technologies raises $1 million in funding


World No Tobacco Day celebrated at ESIC Medical College


Pune doctors perform India’s first uterus transplant surgery


ICMR to test efficacy of two medicines for tackling drug-resistant TB


PGI Chandigarh to have two deans, one for academics and another for research

42 Comments »

Comment by Gulshan Khalil
2012-06-10 18:30:30

FYIP,
I think some ammendment should be happen in the syllabus of AYUSH doctor or given a apportunity all of of them to get the lateral entery in MBBS course after BAMS,BUMS or BHMS .
If we review the syllabus of MBBS as well as AYUSH then we found Syllabus of MBBS and AYUSH totally are same ecept some subject,and they will do modern and old both internship so why these type of activity is being done.
If it is wrong to PRACTICE MODERN MEDICINE for AYUSH DOCTOR.
So I think central should be some change in their syllabus.
This is like as two type of student SCIENCE SIDE and ART SIDE.
So I think whoever want to ineterest in modern medicine should be some option here so that all AYUSH doctor can put theirs skill for future.

 
Comment by ajmal khan
2012-06-15 17:28:14

If we go to the MBBS Syllabus world wide we don’t get the common syllabus and common pattern at all. We see people from Russia, Nepal, Afganistan and other colleges of India don’t have the same calibre and potential but they get entry in allopathic medication practise by a test of MCI. The students of Ayush who got trained and taught modern medicine in syllabus can not do the practise in allopathy, Why ? Is this not a partiality that you allow other countries pass out people who have different syllabus, different mode of teaching, why you don’t allow here people to appear in test. are you afraid of thier calibre, or you have sympathy for those millinoires who can fund in private college MBBS from outside .

 
Comment by Dr.Surender singh
2012-06-21 00:23:33

only thing i want to say,allopathic practionar thinks whatever development happens in biophysics,biochemistry,radiology,or other such sciences are meant for them only no other pathy person can use them.for example: world knows father of surgery and father of plastic surgery is sushrutacharya an ayurvedic surgeon who did surgery for cataract,rhinoplasty,even enterotomy 5000 yrs back,he gave all the basic principal of surgery.now allopathic surgeons of india feels proud when they know that history of surgery in india was so bright and ahead of western world.but what happen to them when they face (M.S) general surgery Ayurveda) does they feel insecure,or jealous or have superiority complex that they end up saying that allopathic doctors are only one who should or can perform surgery,when they themself knows actually surgery is pure handicraftmanship it comes under no pathy.i think they do so because they are somewhere afraid of the talent of ayurvedic surgeons. and if we talk about current syllabus for M.S ayurveda it includes all the surgical procedures (appendectomy,hernioplasty,cholesystectomy,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,)please do refer syllabus at ccim site.

Now i ask the magistrate of allahbad high court or every such person who says we should only do ayurvedic practice by prescribing ayurvedic drugs only:Do you know surgery is one branch out of eight branch of ayurveda? if yes then how can u pass such orders and if no then still how can you pass that order,you should learn first, if a person learns(for total 8.5 year) and practice surgery for 3 yrs of hard word in his m.s course thatt to according to central council syllabus,shall he not practice surgery ,if not? than judge sahab and all allopathic doctors Don’T EVEN DARE TO CALL SUSHRUTACHARYA FATHER OF SURGERY. we will be happy to say him an ancient ayurvedic physician(NOT SURGEON).and believe me you people can never erase his name as father of surgery . you hav no right to say surgery is yours only its for all who can perform it well

 
Comment by Dr.Surender singh
2012-06-21 00:47:18

A serious joke: A person who gets 40 percent marks in 12th standard ,gets 40 percent marks in premadical enterance exam ,gets 40 percent marks in all m.b.b.s subjects,gets 40 percent marks in post graduate enterance exam ,gets 40 percent marks for passing post graduation(surgery,cardiology,medicine and all),and sometimes commit suicide if medium of exam changes to english(that too when all medical science books available are in english language):::::::::::::::::Can practice medicine which is a science of life an saving lives.

ohhhhhh
ohhhhhhh
ooooohhhhhhhhhhhh it means he is certified to kill 60 percent population.
Thats the beauty of 27 percent of indian doctors and no court can stop them.
THIS HAPPENS ONLY IN THESE GREAT TIMES OF SO CALLED ………………….
and pain does not stops here ,if an ayush doctor(who may hav 80 percent marks throughout his studies) saves the life of a person by giving allopathic drugs(WHICH ARE AVAILABLE OVER THE COUNTER AT ANY MEDICAL SHOP )WILL BE PUNISHED BY THOSE WHO ARE unable even to understand the term LIFE.

 
Comment by zahid kamal
2012-06-21 01:01:21

allahabad highcourt judgement is unilateral hearing result,

i want to know from high court( allahabad ) if a person has studied from based on teaching and training from an institution, is not authorised to earn by using this which the person has studied. if yes then you should know the syllabas of BUMS made by CCIM.
this is fundamental right of earning for their lives, by using the skills which the perso has studied from an institutiion based on teaching and training.

, there is need to be rethink about this judgement.

 
Comment by Saikumar G
2012-06-21 08:05:59

Ayurvedic medicine is ancient form of medicine and allopathic medicine is modern medicine.The anatomy will not change in any form of medicine but there is lot of change in pharmacology.There is no objection as long as an ayurvedic doctor prescribes ayurvedic medicines but the fact is that most of the ayurvedic doctors in our country are prescribing allopathic drugs only to treat the patients. These drugs are developed for use by the allopathic doctors who learn about them including the dosage and side effects. The main attraction for patients recieving treatment will be that no money need to be spend on tests and even AIDS has curative treatment.usually the ayush treatment is cheaper than allopathic. The so called reality show by the actor Amirkhan should have a programme on quackery in in India by alternative medicine degree holders and the indifferent attitude of government agencies towards them.

 
Comment by zahid kamal
2012-06-21 09:53:58

Saikumar G posted Ayurvedic medicine is ancient form of medicine and allopathic medicine is modern medicine. Saikumar can u defined and provide the list of allopathic drugs . you should know there is no categorization of drugs on the basis of pathy , actually all these are under drugs and cosmetic act. there are many drugs which are used by AYUSH doctors from ancient time and all these are also used by so called Allopathy doctors now a days.
Saikumar G do u know about the syllabus of BUMS which contain both unani and modern.

Saikumar G, first know the rules then post comment.

 
Comment by dr shahgeel khan
2012-06-21 10:23:48

i m also ayush doctor,,,,our sayllabus and m.b.b.s doctor syllabus is same but why instruction for him…..
Hum ko kyu saza de ja rahe hai,,,,hum sab ko is na insafe ke khilaf awwaz uthane chahey,,,,,
aur apne haq ke liye ladna chaheye,,,,,,

 
Comment by Dr. M. Shariq
2012-06-21 18:13:21

It is not under stood, when Honorable Suprem court( BENCH:of K.T.THOMAS, & SYED SHAH MOHAMMED QUADRI ) has already ordered, allowing Ayush medicos to practice in allopath also along with their system, in Dr. Mukhtiar Chand case vide Final order Dt 8-10-1998.
then why some people are mis guiding the courts and authorities to go against supreme court judgement, Is it clear cut contempt of supreme court .
Those who want copy of above judgement please mail us in drshariq09@rediffmail.com , and strongly oppose such things which is ruining the dignity of qualified medicos.
Dr Shariq

 
Comment by Dr.Abbas
2012-06-21 21:37:17

i am proud to be an AYUSH DOCTOR,If any person comeing outside india is authurised to practice allop.medicine after passing MCI,GOVT SHOULD MAKE AYUSH DOCTORS ELIGIBLY TO MCI TEST,if not possible then govt should close all govt.n pravt AYUSH COLLAGES,so as to prevent the tilent of students born intelligent,,its a bootle neck situation,,we have tilent,but unfortunate our govt shadow it,,,,,,,,,,those who finger against AYUSH DOCTORshould first know the syllbus of AYUSH COURSES then they wil come to know the fact,,,i also say that mbbs course is much much easier then Ayush,it is a double course system involving modern n ISM,

 
Comment by Dr.Surender singh
2012-06-24 15:19:28

you r right but tell me allopathic doctor learn pharmacology according to syllabus and hav right to prescribe the same but when bams dr.learn the same from same books and according to syllabus then why he should be barred to prescribe ,and what do u mean by alternative, have u gone through all the literature available about human life and diseases there is nothing like alternative everything is for treating disesaes, or do you think whatever we get from plant is alternative and whatever is made in factory is mainstream then my dear sir why you are eating alternative food you should eat mainstream food make by a pharmacy can you eat? just open your mind and think and try to define alternative before saying ayurveda as alternative pathy……………………….and realy if you hav time just try to read books written by dr.valliathan a padambhushan winner (cardiothoracic surgeon)named legacy of sushruta,legacy of charaka,legacy of vagbhata you will actually know how developed our system was and is.realy i request you to comment with facts not by emotions

 
Comment by Dr.Surender singh
2012-06-24 15:24:30

the above reply is for saikumar g

 
Comment by Dr.Surender singh
2012-06-24 15:27:22

all who want to comment just go through the syllabus of BAMS and M.S shalya tantra you will know the extant to which we have been tought link is http://www.ccimindia .com

 
Comment by Dr.Surender singh
2012-06-24 15:43:03

if any body hav urge to find evidence based truth then find the 9 oct,2011 issued THE WEEK magazine there is an artical named ANCIENT CARE you will know that some 5500 years ago, in the Harappan civilisation,we hav evidence of surgery being performed on human beings even the orthopadiac surgery like intramadullary nailing which is a complex surgery even in present days .based on discovery of 6th century hospital in chhattishgarh.this is a request to all who hav got balls to face truth not to those who dnt even hav cunt…………..

 
Comment by dr sk chaudhary
2012-06-25 21:22:01

very disappointing order of allahabad high court against ayush doctors.it is a clear cut indication how allopathic doctor’s association(IMA/MCI) is afraid of the knowledge & skills of ayush doctors.IMA/MCI both are making all efforts to cut down the rights of ayush doctors by making continuous pressure on government,by misguiding courts & higher authorties to pass strict orders against ayush doctors ,and .No body is going through the syllabus of BAMS/MD/MS (ayurved) before passing any order against these doctors.according to syllabus we have studied ayurved with morden medicine and got 6 months training in district allopathic hospital as internship IMA/MCI both are manipulating & misleading courts and government and have misconception towards ayush doctors.its a monopoly of allopathic doctors.they are earning lot of money & making their son and daughters an allopathic doctor after paying a big amount as donation in private colleges of india & abroad(russia/china/kazakistan and many more places where language,diseases,climate all are different from our country.there is no facility&faculty for teaching &practical training properly. students are only passing time there & getting degree) at UG and PG level so that they earn more and more money from poor people of country.our government are welcoming such type of doctors in govt job and issuing licence to play with the health of citizens.and on the other hand ayush doctors who have studied & got traning in india from authorized institutions according to syllabus are job less,unauthorized,quacks,& govt has no budget for them &courts are passing continuously orders against them. what is this???? its a conspiracy of IMA/MCI, it is punishment to be an ayush doctor or its punishment for providing treatment on minimal cost to poor & low/medium class of society mostly living in rural areas where allopathic doctors never wish to go.More than 70% of our population is unable to pay high fees& costly treatment of such allopathic doctors.why judicial system &higher authorties of government are not solving this problem.govt is under pressure of IMA/MCI about threat to go on strike.ccim is totally failled body .it is effortless to save the rights of its doctors.it is only making syllabus but not pursuing it in front of court&government. it is injustice!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 
Comment by Dr,lalit kishoremishra.
2012-06-30 18:52:49

s ir i want to say some thing about high court order . i,m bams of 1978. in my deggree provided by kanpur university mentioned bam.s (BECHLAR OF AYUVER WITH MODERN MEDICINE AND SURGURY).
now court says that we shoisould use only ayurved.they says that this degree povided by university we are not autherise for modern medicine and surgury. .at the time of admission in ayu.college i was student not a lawyer to know lagal position of degree. what is ayu.or modern medicine i,e,.issaltand water by mouth is ayurved?and sod. chloride inj. is allopathy?bymouth is ayurved ?by vein allopathy?Hon,ble high court say no operation allowed by i.s.m. doctor.what do mean by surgury.blade forcep thread is allopathy ? In role of cotton on raper noted i.p. then can ayu.doctor touch or use it .ok we used previously ay.injectable awailable in market. m.c.i.and ima made a presser to ban it. they bacame success full
x-ray ,ultrasoun,endoscopy is not a reaserch of allopath doctor but scientific reaserch.but.reserve for allopath.
cause-we are devide in many organisation.not united for example ayu.congress.nima anew ayusma.manyothers inhindi apani dhapli apana apna rag.for sucess it is neccessory to unite make only onestrong organisation.and support it .next in new blog

 
Comment by dr.a.k.patra
2012-07-05 02:25:55

Let the entire matter goes to The Hon’able Supreme court of India to give guidelines to the entire states of india and neccessary correction in medical practice should be pronounced for all stakeholders of healthcare..

 
Comment by Dr. Dilip shetty
2012-07-07 13:45:32

I m agree with ur statement sir.

 
Comment by Dr.Satyadev sahani
2012-07-07 14:05:45

Court should already aware before taking an action against AYUSH doctors,they should know that ancient fater of surgery was shusurta and his path was also ayurveda ,thats why AYUSH doctors have power to do all the such things no body can stop them because ayurveda doctors are more tallent than MBBS doctors, ayurveda doctors are spreading their tallent everywhere and Allopathic doctors become low in front of them ,and i want to tell all MBBS doctors that ,one day a day will come where all world will bend towars ayurveda when people will become aware against allopathic medicines,they wole will turn towards ayurveda, one day will also came ,where allopathic doctors will sitting in their clinic and no more pateints were their ,that,s day will come soon,

 
Comment by Dr.Sabir
2012-07-07 21:37:00

The right of practitioners of Indian Medicine to practice modern scientific system of Medicine (Allopathic Medicine) is protected under Section 17(3)(b) of Indian Medicine Central Council Act, 1970.

 
Comment by SYED ABU ADAM
2012-07-09 12:38:45

ya…I’m completely agree with u….b’coz syllabus is same……even.ayush doctors have extra syllabus in comparison to mbbs doctors,,,,,,,so….why they differ from mbbs…..

 
Comment by DrRavinder
2012-07-11 11:40:54

Dear Drs namaskar,main aap sabhi se agree hu..ccim notification F.NO.8-5/2003 AY MM clear kia gaya hai ke ism doctor modern medicine main practice kar sakte hain.jo CCIM SECRETORY PR SHARMA DWARA JARI KIA HAI..AND tamilnadu govt ne bhi ism doctor ko modern medicine main practice karne ke liye allow kia hai.and supreme court ne bhi Dr mukhtiar chand nd ors v.the state of punjab nd ors 1998 rd sc 491 (8oct 1998 ) supreme ke order main ism doctor ko allopathy main practice karne ke liye allow kia hai.dear drs ye sabhi satement aap internet par google par search karke nikal sakte hai.ye sabhi net par avialable hain..hum sabhi drs up main hue dr par lathicharge ke ninda karte hain….up main tv par dikha rhe the ke govt hospital main doctor absent rehte hain nd swiper operation karte hain .govt ko ye sab nhi dikhta hai .aise hi har village main jhola chaap bogus doctor practice kar rhe hai jo 8th 10 th pass hote hain apne clinic par allopathic and ayurvedic medicine patients ko dete hain .

 
Comment by DrRavinder
2012-07-11 18:48:24

According to the privileges in the drug and cosmetics act 1945 sec 2ee( ¡¡¡),state have right to allow ism doctor to use modern medicine in the practice..as long as for yrs after 1969,ccim recognised ism doctors now included as RMP in 2 -ee-\\\,of the drug act on 23 feb 1999 by a special notification…..bams bhms bums and bsms doctors 5year 6 month course ke baad hi related council main regiser hote hain tabhi practice karte hain.lekin agar govt main gutz hain to bogus jhola chaap doctor ke khilaph action le.in bogus doctor par allopathy and ayurvedic medicine dene par koi action nhi hota .ye jhola chaap doctor har village small town main apne clinic khol ke baithen hain…govt qualified doctors par pabandi lagate hain…..asli khatra to patients ko in jhola chaap doctor se hai…ism qualified doctor mbbs ke equivalent hain ..jai hind jai bharat..

 
Comment by Dr.Q.M.Anzar Ranavat
2012-07-14 00:05:57

according to the supreme court,duration time,internshp time,admission seats,entrance test (c.p.m.p),syllabus,and all cases all ayush doctor B.U.M.S,B.A.M.S and B.H.M.S are equellent to the allopathy doctor…so the judgment of the sunil ambwani is a epsoluotly wrong…

 
Comment by RamanSingh
2012-07-16 15:01:00

Medicine arose out of sympathy .Medicine developed and flourished by chains of experiences of various trials 0f remedies on plant human and animals.In Ayrevedic concept every thing is composed of panch mahabhoot either human body or various plants.All the plant mineral and the environment effect our body to either produce the disease or to cure them .So nothing is in the world which can not be used as medicine provided you know the effect on human body.
Ayurveda was flourished till tenth century in its eight branches-Surgery,Medicine,Gyn.Obs,Eye ENT,Toxicology,Geriatrics and sexology,Pediatrics etc.This knowledge transfered to the whole world .we never claimed that the said subjects are ours only .we did not behaved as we have patented the medical sciences.we made it easily availble to human kind for benefits of tha poorers.
Presently to development ayurveda has adopted modern advances for better treatment,and medical research . when we combine Ayurveda with Modern we get excellent results . For example
—1-minimum dose of Ciplox TZ 125 mg with chitrakadi bati and kutaj ghanbati give good results in amoeb.dirrhoea with no side effect of ciplox TZ.
-2-Hemostatic with asokarist ,pradarantak loh,pusyanug churn in uterine bleeding
-3-antiallergic for short duration with mahamanjistharist,gandhak rasayan,arogyawardhini,marichyadi tail,
-4-Ayurvedic laparoscopic surgeons along with lap. chole got experience of ayurvedic drugs disolving gall stones with arogyabardhini,abhayarist and chitrakadibati
-5- ayurvedic colorectal surgeons treat 100 % fistula cases when combine surgery with kshar-sutra.
These examples are only few of a vast experiences which is beneficial to the patients . so patients has no complains against us
By professional jelous a well organised association has come forward to cease our rights to practice accoding to teaching and training They behave like they have patented the medical advances.
LASTLY IS DESH KA KANOON ANDHA HAI..JO KEWAL EK ASSOCIATION KE NAJARO SE KANNON KO DEKHATA.HAI.
WHAT IS AYURVED ONLY CAN BE DEFINED BY THOSE WHO ARE RESPONSIBLE BODY FOR TEACHING AND TRANING OF AYURVEDA.NEITHER THE COURT NOR THE ASSOCIATION
Before passing an order the court never asked the sufferer and had put the Ayurvedic practitioners under the groups of JHOLA CHHAP.They make the learned ayurvedist a criminals and sending to jail.This can be compered as KALA KANOON OF BRITISH RULE. ,

 
Comment by A.Sami
2012-07-23 17:51:14

Before taking any decision state govt.s as well as Honorable Courts should at least go through following three thing . 1. B.A.M.S./B.U.M.S. Syllabus Available with http://www.ccimindia.org in which, all is included anatomy, physiology,pathology,hygiene social & preventive medicine,pharmacology,toxicology medical jurisprudence,medicine,ophthalmology,ENT,surgery,gynae& obs, pediatrics according to both ayurvedic& modern scientific medicine in theoretical&practical manner during 4.5 yrs BAMS curriculum. dissection of dead body & rotatory internship of one year in which 6 months of allopathy in dist.gov. hospital was included. why cant practice for the same . 2. Supreme Court Verdict in the matter of DR. MUKHTIAR CHAND & ORS.Vs.THE STATE OF PUNJAB & ORS. . 3. Minister for Health & Family Welfare, Dr. Anbumani Ramadoss in a written reply to a question in the Rajya Sabha. If you feel problem in finding the last two things please mail us in drshariq09@rediffmail.com , This fact has already been accepted by supreme court in the above decision and named it ‘Integrated courses’ and find the above courses sufficient to practice allopath along with their system of practice. The only obstacle is State laws, which are restraining the qualified Dr. to use their skills/ knowledge which they gained in completing these courses. Introducing the one-year pharmacology course, is use less if they are going to award any post graduation degree, then all right, we well come the decision, In fact CCIM should amend the name of these courses as follows, . 1. B.A.M.S. Bachelor of Ayurvedic & Modern Medicines with Surgery And . 2. B.U.M.S. Bachelor of Unani & Modern Medicines with Surgery , So that some of our Qabil Dosts could not misguide, the Courts and Govt.s and general Public. If above is not possible Govts should ask the CCIM to remove modern/ Allopath studies from their syllabus for future and stop cheating the students. And compensate the losses of dr.s who have already completed the integrated courses, with the hope that they will be allowed to practice all what they are being Taught & Trained. .A. Sami

 
Comment by DR. SURYA PRAKASH TADEPALLI
2012-08-31 23:07:59

WHAT WAS THE SYSTEM OF MEDICINE USED BY THE PEOPLE BEFORE JESUS CHRIST?

It is to say, Ayurveda is the mother for other system of medicine. Ayurveda is not alternative to Allopathy system of medicine. Allopathy and other systems of medicine are alternative to Ayurveda. As you know, before Jesus Christ Allopathy is not introduced that time Egyptians, Western countries etc were followed Ayurveda system of medicine because it is introduced/originated thousands of years back which is documented. The great father of medicine Hippocrates came Takshashila University of India to learn about surgery, anatomy and dravyaguna (Indian Pharmacology). Who was remained grateful to Indian system of medicine. After Indian tour he went back to his native country and described about great formulation and surgical procedures of Indian system.
Atropine is an alkaloid extract of Atropina Belladona plant of Indian Medicinal Plants. Absence of atropina belladona there will be no ophthalmology development, because refractive errors may not be identified. Atropine is an important alkaloid in bradycardia and in organophosphorus poisoning. In the same way vinblastine and vincristine are the extracts of winca rosacea and winca sinosa which are mainly used in the the treatment of leukemia and blood cancer which belong to Indian medicinal Plants. In the same way digoxine from digitalis purpura, Acetyle salicylic acid from white willow, narcotics and sedative are derivatives of opium. 80% of alkaloids are extracted from Indian medicinal Plants. Whole world known fact that father of surgery is the great Sushrutha who has done many surgical procedures include transplantation.
The history is there behind Ayurveda system of medicine its a unique system of medicine which has many typical dimensions to diagnose a disease without application of latest bio medical technologies. In this system of medicine all the students have to study all disciplines like Allopathy as well as other systems like Naturopathy, Homoeopathy and one emergency medicine paper (Allopathy) are also be studied compulsory. In addition to that Sanskrit a very typical language is compulsory to every student. Comparatively Allopathy, Ayurveda is more tougher. An Ayurveda doctor can diagnose and treat a patient simply unlike allopathy doctors because they have based on modern laboratory investigations. The latest medical technology is developed rapidly which access easy in diagnosis in any system of medicine. It is not a big task to prescribe allopathy medicine because most of the medicine coming from Indian medicinal Plants especially formulated in Ayurveda medicine. Its a sincere request to the people and the governments should not look down Ayurveda system of medicine originated in ancient era and at the same time it is the mother system to all other systems of medicine. All systems have its unique specialties and we have no right to under estimate any system.

Dr. Surya Prakash Tadepalli
M.Sc (Clinical Microbiology); BAMS; MBA (Hospital Management); MA; M.Phil; PGDY; PGDCPA; DNHE; D. Pharmacy
Cell: 09849153488
E-Mail:urwithdaring@yahoo.co.in

 
Comment by Y.Rajagopal
2012-09-01 14:28:08

Allopathy is not like ayurveda where keen observation and experience is passed on through generations regarding the plants and other materials having medicinal value. Allopathy is dependent on different diagnostic tests and pharmacological industry. In allopathy system, the effects and side effects of drugs are first tested in clinical drug trials and then approved for clinical use. But still many new undesirable effects of a particular approved drug are being published.How an ayurvedic or homeopathic doctor can take the responsibility if patient dies after consuming a particular allopathic drug about which he did not know much.I am very much impressed by the comments of Dr Surya prakash T and I always say that what you read and learnt is easy to practice. Copying other medical system and prescribing allopathic drug may pose problems because of its side effects or no effect. Patient will blame the doctor only and not the drug. No allopathic doctor or police will come to your rescue if patient dies while taking allopathic drug injection.

 
Comment by bino
2012-09-29 08:11:30

totally agreeable for lateral entry

 
Comment by DR. SURYA PRAKASH TADEPALLI
2012-11-03 18:59:02

WHAT WAS THE SYSTEM OF MEDICINE USED BY THE PEOPLE BEFORE JESUS CHRIST?

It is to say that Ayurveda is the mother for other systems of medicine. Ayurveda is not alternative to Allopathy system of medicine. Allopathy and other systems of medicine are alternative to Ayurveda. As you know, before Jesus Christ Allopathy is not introduced that time, Egyptians, Western countries etc were followed Ayurveda system of medicine because it is introduced/originated thousands of years back which were documented. The great father of medicine Hippocrates came Takshashila University of India to learn surgery, anatomy and dravyaguna (Indian Pharmacology). Who was remained grateful for ever to Indian system of medicine. After Indian tour, he went back to his native country and described about great formulations, surgical procedures and greatness of Indian system of medicine.
Atropine is an alkaloid extracted from the plant Atropina Belladona belong to Indian Medicine. Absence of the plant atropina belladona we can not see the ophthalmological developments because refractive errors can not be identified without atropine drops. Atropine is an important alkaloid indicated in bradycardia and is vital use in organophosphorus poisoning. More over vinblastirne and vincristine are the alkaloids extract from winca rosacea and winca sinosa mainly used in the the treatment of leukemia and blood cancer, these plants belong to Indian medicinal Plants. In the same way digoxine from digitalis purpura, Acetyle salicylic acid from white willow, narcotics and sedative are derivatives of opium. 80% of alkaloids are extracted from Indian medicinal Plants. Whole world known fact is that the father of surgery is great Sushrutha who is legend for surgery has done many surgical procedures include transplantation and plastic surgeries.
Thee is a vast history behind Ayurveda system of medicine, its a unique system of medicine which has many typical dimensions to diagnose a disease without application of latest bio medical technologies. In this system of medicine students have to study all disciplines like Allopathy in addition to that also have to study Naturopathy, Homoeopathy and one subject of emergency medicine (Allopathy) is compulsory. In addition to that Sanskrit a very typical language is compulsory be qualified by every student. Comparatively Allopathy, Ayurveda is more tougher. An Ayurveda doctor can diagnose and treat a patient simply unlike to allopathy doctors because they will base on modern laboratory investigations. The latest medical technology is developed rapidly which access easy in diagnosis in any system of medicine. It is not a big task to prescribe allopathy medicine because most of the medicine coming from Indian medicinal Plants especially formulated in Ayurvedic system of medicine. Its a sincere request to the people and the governments should not look down Ayurveda system of medicine originated in ancient era and more over it is the mother system to all other systems of medicine. All systems have its unique specialties and we have no right to under estimate any system.

Dr. Surya Prakash Tadepalli
M.Sc (Clinical Microbiology); BAMS; MBA (Hospital Management); MA; M.Phil; PGDY; PGDCPA; DNHE; D. Pharmacy
Cell: 09849153488
E-Mail:urwithdaring@yahoo.co.in

 
Comment by Dr. M C Gupta, Advocate
2012-11-06 22:24:52

Reply to the Comment by Gulshan Khalil, who wrote–

–”I think some ammendment should be happen in the syllabus of AYUSH doctor or given a apportunity all of of them to get the lateral entery in MBBS course after BAMS,BUMS or BHMS”.

***

OK. Let the government do two things simultaneously:

1–Allow lateral entry for AYUSH to join MBBS after appearng in the regular entrance examination with relaxation of 2.5% in the score received by them in the entrance exam. (meaning thereby that let the score attained by them be enhanced by 2.5% as grace marks), giving unlimited chances / attempts to them.

2–Reduce admission capacity to AYUSH colleges by 10% every year and stop opening new AYUSH colleges.

–M C Gupta
MD, LLM, Advocate

 
Comment by Dr. M Banik
2012-12-12 22:49:38

Why not stopping sanctioning any new so called modern medical colleges by MCI from where the official people only makes transaction of some legal and mostly illegal money, there by compromising the standard of medical education. Instead the existing ayush colleges can be upgraded, leading to saving of people’s money and time, without making any compromisation with the education standard.

And on 2.5% grace marks – let there be no grace marks, and let the entrance exam for all the post-graduation courses i.e MD, MS and Diplomas of all pathies be open to all. The real talent will be reveled.

Dr. M. Banik.

 
Comment by dr vivek pandey
2012-12-14 00:45:16

i wanna say a small thing that discoverer of homoeopathy was dr hahnemann who was a renowned allopathic practioner, but was very much disappointed with the results of allopathy & then he discovered homoeopathy, so think about it & try to be impartial about doctors rights.
thank u all of u

 
Comment by Dr.parvez khan
2012-12-18 19:03:29

aj hamara sangathan bahut kamjor hai hamaray jo neta hai wo kuch karna nahi chahtay. aj jo dist par jo ayush dr.post kiye gaye hai na to unko chamber mila hai nahi un ko salary 5 -6month ho gaye hai na c.m.o na c.m.s.ko un ki parvah hai medicine ka pata nahi hamara yahi kahna hai sangathan ko majboot banay system ko change karna hai to ak sath rahay….

 
Comment by pragash
2013-01-22 17:44:59

why yu guys dont practise the medicine where yu have studied the supreme court has told if yu are practising any other form of medicine accept yours yu are a quack ther is no need to say that allopathic is same and ayush systemis same if it was so no surgery would have occured in the world everybody would have prescribed herbs a mbbs doctor has to undergo 5 years of training in medicine he is really fit to prescribe the allopathic form of medicine the next thing doctors studying from abroad they have to pass a very strict exam conducted by dnb board the exam is very though forget about this yu wont be able to answer a single answer in maharashtra homopathic, ayvedic colleges are mourishing like dew drops they belong to all politicians pay 50,000 rupees yu will get admission

 
Comment by mujahid shaikh
2013-11-27 07:32:28

yes sir I agree with u in internship we are teached allopathy and said to practice our own pathy after completion

 
Comment by Dr.P.V.Krishnamohan
2014-10-06 20:35:22

dear sirs., my opinion is that rules are hard and fast.It is the primary duty of any Doctor of any system to save the person who is in crisis.no discussion for time pass will not help the victim to die.Firstly every doctor has the right to administer any medicine of any system provided if he HAS the essential knowledge of the drug that he is giving to the victim.for exam one can save a drowning person with any type of the rope either it is made by an indian or europion.Humanitarian sence THAT requires.

 
Comment by Atmaram Llb
2014-10-09 18:07:10

Dosto bade sharm ki baat hai ki sab log kewal jubani bahas kar rahe hai. Ek amendment application file karni hai aapko apne high court me PIL ke dwara.
enclosure use karna hai aapko.
1.medical entrance examination press release.
2.highlited BAMS/BHMS/BAMS
3.syllabus
4.books name with English subtitles
5.duration with practical and teachers qualification
6.practical done with dead body
7.practical done by skeleton
7.books where modern medicine is used.
8.ccim inIndia list
9.internship no objection certificates of various departments.
10.payment during internship
11.Master of surgery/MD/MS in gynae entrance test press release.
12.MBBS if plain and has no authentic specialisation also can not open a nursing home.
13.request should be court to stop those plain doctors can not open nursing home they only open clinics.
14.all nursing home have MBBS doctors for 24 hours but mainly they take help ayush doctors.
15.is tara mere Dosto saare MBBS kewal nursing home me as duty doctor ho Jayenge.
16.Saare nursing home me kama karne wale staff ki list Rti se by CMO se mangney ka program chedd divide.

 
Comment by Atmaram Llb
2014-10-09 18:26:11

Iske alawa CHC/PHC me avaliable drugs patients condition/surgery/hospitalizations/refer why RTI se list maangi jaa sakti hai yarrow
Iske alawa mere dosto ek baat kahna chahunga ki BAMS/BUMS/BHMS/SIDDHA walo se
se ki kuch apne me hi bhaiyo me se surgen ke baap ban jaate hai jabki kewal diagnosis ke base pe treatment chalate to aaj unko ye mauka na milta.
Lekin bina allopath ke aap jee kha nahi sakte to dhandha badal do aur logo media se ye batai ki BAMS/BHMS/BUMS ye sab jhola chaap degree hai inhe na padhe ya iski jagah doosra kaam kar le.
Court ko shayad ye nahi pata hoga ki highschoo/inter fail/ya electro/naturo/acupressure ye sab bogus aur jholachap hai na ki professional qualified log.
apne haq ki ladai khud lado aur syastem ki naak me dam karte hue saare paper collect karke uska use bataiye
nahi to padhe likhe hokar chor jaise darte darte buisness karo health department ka babu peon bhi apne ko garv se kahta vahi agar aapko dhaunsh deta hai to phat jaati hai aapki.

 
Comment by Nikhil
2014-11-22 01:44:45

in India
compounder/nurses/chemists/pharmacist/non qualified rmp’s are doctors and can practice any system of medicine & even surgeries in govt. establishments but an institutionally qualified ayush doctor is called quack by MCI and jholashaap by desi angrej doctors.
well hope the system will change
or else whi baat hai…ye andha kaanoon
mera bharat mahaan

 
Comment by B. Debnath
2015-07-17 08:27:15

This is not an appropriate step done by UP govt. Please try to solve un-employment problem then all will solve automatically. Please try to keep MBBS doctors , in each and every villages of India first where communication is problematic and we need to visit there by walking or bi-cycle. We are the poor people and we can not effort the consultation fee of MBBS doctors for each and every period. Is it possible to solve by the govt. Please think , govt. has employed some 4th grade health workers for villeges and they are permitted to give allopathic medicines, are they MBBS ? So think about this and take action. All the medical shop they are serving allopathic medicine without prescription , are they MBBS ? It means who are taking action against this matter, either they are not properly realistic on this matter or they have some other interest on this matter.

 
Comment by Udaybhanu verma
2018-05-04 09:31:14

Kiya mai B.A.fainal ke bad dactor ban Sakta hu

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.